TL;DR
In an online survey experiment, participants were about 19 percentage points less likely to recommend life-sustaining treatment for a seriously ill patient with dementia than for one without dementia. Advance directives affected recommendations, but the difference by dementia status persisted even when patients’ documented wishes called for treatment.
Participants in a survey were about 19 percentage points less likely to recommend life-sustaining treatment for a seriously ill patient with dementia than for a similar patient without dementia, even when an advance directive requested treatment, according to a University of Colorado Anschutz study published in JAMA Network Open. The findings suggest that a patient’s diagnosis and a surrogate’s views may shape recommendations alongside documented preferences.
Turn quiet afternoons into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
The randomized online experiment surveyed nearly 6,000 U.S. adults. Participants read scenarios about seriously ill, hospitalized older adults and were asked what care they would recommend. Researchers varied whether the patient had dementia, whether an advance directive requested life-sustaining or comfort-focused care, and whether a physician recommended treatment.
For patients with dementia and no advance directive, participants recommended life-sustaining treatment in 15.6% of scenarios. That share was 41.0% when the directive requested life-sustaining care and 7.6% when it requested comfort-focused care. For patients without dementia, the corresponding figures were 38.9%, 66.3% and 14.4%.
The researchers said the pattern indicates that advance directives influenced recommendations, but did not remove the difference associated with dementia status. The study also found that the preferences of the person making decisions for the patient mattered. The results describe responses to hypothetical scenarios; they do not establish how often clinicians or families make the same choices in actual care.
How Dementia Shaped Recommendations
The results highlight a potential gap between a person’s documented treatment preferences and the recommendations made on their behalf. If a patient cannot communicate, a surrogate may help guide decisions. A recommendation that reflects the surrogate’s own views about dementia or quality of life, rather than the patient’s expressed wishes, could affect care discussions.
The study does not show that actual treatment was withheld or that every surrogate would discount a directive. It measures survey participants’ recommendations in constructed cases. Still, the difference matters because advance directives are meant to communicate preferences for future situations in which a person may be unable to speak for themselves.
The findings also point to the role of conversations beyond paperwork. Naming a decision-maker and recording preferences are parts of planning, but the researchers say it is also important for that person to understand the patient’s values and know how those values apply to treatment choices.
Products Worth Considering

Therabody Theragun Prime 6th Generation Deep Tissue Massage Gun, Navy

LEVOIT Vital 200S-P Smart Air Purifier for Large Rooms, White

Garmin Forerunner 245 Music GPS Running Smartwatch, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
What the Survey Tested
An advance directive records a person’s preferences for future medical care if they become unable to communicate or make decisions. A surrogate decision-maker is someone authorized or selected to make health care decisions for a patient who cannot make or communicate them.
In this study, researchers used a randomized survey experiment rather than following patients through hospital treatment. The scenarios allowed them to compare responses as patient diagnosis, directive instructions and physician recommendations changed. The article reporting the research was published in JAMA Network Open in October 2026; the study’s DOI is 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2026.37691.
The report cites earlier research suggesting that more than two-thirds of older adults may eventually face a situation in which another person makes end-of-life medical decisions for them. That estimate is background cited by the report, not a result of the new survey.
“People’s assumptions about what life is like with dementia appear to play an important role in how they think about treatment decisions.”
— Lauren Hersch Nicholas, study lead author and professor of medicine at the University of Colorado Anschutz School of Medicine
Limits of the Survey Findings
The survey measured what participants said they would recommend in hypothetical scenarios. It does not show what patients actually received, how real surrogates respond in clinical settings, or whether the same pattern holds across different communities and health systems. The report does not provide enough detail to determine how participants’ personal experience with dementia affected their answers.
The results also do not establish why recommendations differed. The researchers said assumptions about life with dementia may play a role, but the survey findings alone cannot confirm that explanation or identify the reasoning of each participant. The reported percentages describe recommendations across scenarios, not the share of real patients who received a particular treatment.
It is also unclear from the source report how strongly physician recommendations affected decisions across each combination of scenario details. The study varied that factor, but the figures reported in the article focus on dementia status and advance-directive instructions.
More Planning Conversations Ahead
The research points toward ongoing advance-care-planning discussions as a practical response: patients can explain what matters to them, discuss possible care choices with a prospective surrogate and revisit those conversations as circumstances change. Nicholas said that having a directive alone may not show whether it still reflects a person’s wishes or whether the decision-maker understands them.
The source report does not announce a follow-up study, policy change or clinical guideline arising from the results. The next step for readers is therefore not a specific scheduled milestone, but further research into how documented preferences and surrogate views shape decisions in real clinical care. The study’s findings are evidence about survey recommendations, not individual medical advice.
Key Questions
What did the study find?
Survey participants were about 19 percentage points less likely to recommend life-sustaining treatment for a seriously ill patient with dementia than for one without dementia, even when an advance directive requested treatment.
Did advance directives affect participants’ recommendations?
Yes. For patients with dementia, recommendations for life-sustaining treatment rose from 15.6% with no directive to 41.0% when a directive requested treatment. The directive mattered, but the difference associated with dementia status persisted.
Were these real patient treatment decisions?
No. The research was a randomized online survey experiment in which participants responded to scenarios. It did not track treatment delivered to actual patients.
What does the study suggest about choosing a surrogate?
The authors say patients may want to choose someone who understands their values and is willing to represent their wishes. They also recommend discussing preferences over time, rather than relying only on a written directive.
Source: rss
