TL;DR
A study of nearly 6,800 adults aged 50 and older in Ireland found no consistent association between eating more yogurt and cheese and stronger grip, better mobility or lower frailty after researchers adjusted for other factors. The cross-sectional findings do not show whether fermented dairy affects muscle health over time or whether changing intake would make a difference.
A study of nearly 6,800 adults aged 50 and older in Ireland found no consistent link between eating more yogurt, cheese and other fermented dairy foods and stronger muscles, better mobility or lower frailty. The researchers said associations seen in unadjusted comparisons generally weakened after accounting for differences such as age, activity and socioeconomic factors.
Turn quiet afternoons into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
The analysis, published in the European Journal of Nutrition, combined data from two population-based cohorts: 2,791 participants in NICOLA in Northern Ireland and 3,999 in TILDA in the Republic of Ireland. Participants were at least 50 years old; their average ages were 64 and 66, respectively. The research team included scientists from institutions in Ireland and the United Kingdom.
Participants reported how often they ate certain foods over the previous year. Researchers assessed physical function using hand-grip strength, a timed mobility test and reported difficulties with everyday self-care. They also classified participants using a frailty index based on 30 health deficits. Because the two cohorts used different food questionnaires, intake was not measured identically: NICOLA data included daily amounts of several fermented dairy foods, while TILDA recorded yogurt and cheese and was analyzed as approximate consumption frequency.
In both cohorts, some initial comparisons associated higher intake with weaker grip strength; some also suggested slightly faster mobility test times or fewer activity limitations. Most of these patterns were no longer apparent after adjustment for potential confounding factors, and researchers found no clear dose-response pattern. In one adjusted TILDA analysis, the highest-intake group had more than twice the odds of low grip strength compared with the lowest-intake group. The authors considered that result potentially spurious because it did not appear in analyses using grip strength as a continuous measure or in other outcomes.
What the Findings Say About Muscle Health
Muscle strength and mobility are closely tied to older adults’ ability to remain independent, so foods that might support muscle health are of practical interest. Dairy provides protein, but this study does not support a simple conclusion that eating more yogurt or cheese is associated with better muscle function in these populations.
The findings are not evidence that fermented dairy harms muscles, nor do they establish that it has no effects. Rather, the measured associations were inconsistent and largely did not persist after adjustment. For readers, the main takeaway is that this analysis alone cannot justify treating yogurt or cheese as a proven way to prevent age-related muscle decline.
Products Worth Considering
Therabody Theragun Relief Massage Gun, 3-Speed, Black
Therabody JetBoots Prime Wireless Compression Boots, Regular, 30–34 in Inseam
Garmin Forerunner® 165 Running Smartwatch 43mm Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Irish Cohorts Were Compared
Age-related loss of muscle mass and strength, often described as sarcopenia, can contribute to reduced physical performance and frailty. Protein is relevant to muscle maintenance, but the study background notes that older adults may respond less strongly to protein intake than younger people. Researchers also raised the possibility that fermented foods could relate to muscle through interactions involving the gut, sometimes described as the gut-muscle axis.
That rationale does not establish a benefit. The study was a cross-sectional analysis, comparing reported food habits with health and function measures rather than following participants to test what happened after a change in diet. The cohorts were analyzed separately, with models progressively accounting for factors including age, sex, body mass index, physical activity, smoking, alcohol use, income and education. NICOLA models also included energy and protein intake and area deprivation.
“The findings provided no consistent evidence that higher yogurt or cheese consumption was independently associated with better muscle strength, physical function, or lower frailty in older adults.”
— Study authors, as summarized in the report
Limits of the Available Evidence
The cross-sectional design cannot establish whether fermented dairy intake caused any difference in muscle function, or determine how changes in diet might affect strength over time. Food intake was self-reported, and the questionnaires differed between cohorts; in TILDA, the combined yogurt-and-cheese measure represented frequency rather than a precise daily amount.
It is also unclear whether particular products, serving sizes, dietary patterns or timing of protein intake relate differently to muscle outcomes. The results do not establish an ideal dairy intake, and the isolated low-grip finding in TILDA does not demonstrate harm. Further research would be needed to test whether specific foods or dietary changes affect muscle health.
Further Research on Diet and Strength
The study reports an analysis of existing cohort data; the source material does not identify a planned follow-up date or a specific next study. Researchers would need evidence that tracks dietary intake and muscle outcomes over time, or tests dietary changes, to clarify whether fermented dairy has a causal role.
For now, the results offer a measured update rather than a dietary prescription: higher yogurt and cheese intake was not consistently linked to better muscle outcomes in these cohorts, while the effects of particular foods, amounts and longer-term changes remain unsettled.
Key Questions
Did the study find that yogurt and cheese strengthen aging muscles?
No. The analysis found no consistent association between higher fermented dairy intake and better grip strength, mobility or frailty measures after adjustment for other factors.
How many people were included?
The researchers analyzed 6,790 participants: 2,791 from NICOLA in Northern Ireland and 3,999 from TILDA in the Republic of Ireland.
Does the study show that yogurt or cheese harms muscle strength?
No. One adjusted TILDA analysis found higher odds of low grip strength in the highest-intake group, but the authors regarded it as potentially spurious because it was not reproduced in other measures or outcomes. The overall findings were inconsistent.
Can the results show whether fermented dairy affects muscle health over time?
No. This was a cross-sectional analysis, not a trial or a study tracking dietary changes and later muscle outcomes. It cannot establish cause and effect.
Source: news-medical.net
